I chose the “Denial”
by David Lehman. This poem immediately caught my attention. Not because it was
short and that it would be an easy read but for how simplistic it was. This is which, bothered me.
I began to
read this poem over and over trying to decipher a deeper meaning…
The poem is
called denial… and this character that is depicted is in… well denial… about
being hungover. So he proceeds to reiterate that he isn’t hungover…
…..
Throughout the
entirety of the poem, the author uses four words: I, Am, Not, Hungover. Challenging,
I thought, to critique a poem with a limited amount of words. The only thing
other than rearranging the words around, the author italicizes some words to
provide emphasis for that particular word.
On that note,
it begins to sounds like a theatre exercise to warm the vocal cords before a
play rather than a poem:
“I am
not hungover.
I am not hungover.
Not
hungover am I.
Am I
hungover? Not!”
Seriously
makes me question the vitality of this poem as a professional work.
Perhaps
the author wanted it that way? For us to infer what we want? So lets say this
is what he wants.
This doesn’t
sound as a normal person in denial maybe suffering from alcoholism. For me, this
poem takes on a One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s
Nest feel. Possibly a patient in a mental
hospital that is suffering from an illness. Perhaps his father was an alcoholic,
and his mother got into arguments with his father over him being hungover from
a night of drinking. Defending himself, his father, would utter the words “I’m
not hungover, I’m not hungover, I’M NOT HUNGOVER!”
Perhaps
this child had those words imprinted into his mind before he was sent to the institution.
And in later years we find him setting on the floor, grasping his knees,
rocking back and forth reiterating “I’m not hungover. I’m not hungover.”
Perhaps
I’m all wrong in my assumption. The author wants the simplicity and there is no back story to be had.
It makes me question this poem, and in the end maybe that's the point.

Tyler, I actually enjoyed how you tried to pull deeper meaning out of this very short poem. I never thought of the mental patient view of this poem and to be honest, it makes the poem much more interesting and honestly I hope you're right.
ReplyDeleteThank you sir. I think it put a spin on it.
Delete